top of page

Overhauling India’s Criminal Justice System: Key Differences Between Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 and the Criminal Procedure Code, 1973

Writer: Bharat SinghBharat Singh
Nov 13, 20245 min read

India’s criminal justice system, rooted in the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) of 1973, has long been criticized for its procedural inefficiencies, outdated provisions, and lack of victim and citizen protections. In 2023, India introduced a new legislative framework, the Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), as part of a broader reform package to replace the CrPC and address long-standing issues. BNSS, 2023, aims to modernize the criminal justice process by making it faster, fairer, and more transparent. This article explores the key differences between BNSS, 2023, and the CrPC, 1973, along with the implications of these reforms.

1. Strengthening Citizens' Rights and Protecting Human Dignity

One of the most significant changes in BNSS is its focus on protecting citizens' rights and ensuring fair treatment throughout the criminal justice process. BNSS, 2023, includes several provisions to safeguard the rights of individuals during detention and interrogation, aiming to reduce instances of abuse and mistreatment.

Key Changes:

  • Right Against Custodial Torture: BNSS includes strict protocols to prevent custodial torture, mandating that suspects' rights are respected. Detention procedures now include regular health checks and mandatory access to legal counsel.

  • Legal Representation and Counsel: Under BNSS, suspects are granted more robust access to legal counsel from the time of their detention, ensuring that they are informed of their rights, which was only implicitly encouraged in the CrPC.

By explicitly defining these rights, BNSS aims to prevent the misuse of authority and improve transparency and accountability within the criminal justice system.

2. Emphasis on Digitization and Technological Integration

In a major push towards modernizing the justice system, BNSS prioritizes digital transformation across procedural stages, from complaint registration to evidence documentation. CrPC, drafted in 1973, did not account for digital processes, which often led to heavy paperwork and inefficiencies.

Key Changes:

  • E-Filing and Digital Case Management: BNSS enables electronic filing of complaints and petitions, allowing individuals to file complaints online, thus reducing paperwork and streamlining the filing process.

  • Digital Evidence and Record Maintenance: Under BNSS, evidence and witness statements can be recorded digitally and stored in secure databases. The CrPC required physical records, which often contributed to documentation delays and mismanagement.

  • Digital Trial Monitoring: To prevent delays, BNSS allows for the remote monitoring of cases and the use of digital tools for case tracking, enabling judges and lawyers to stay updated on the status of each case.

3. Streamlining Investigation and Trial Timelines

Delays in criminal investigations and trials have been a significant problem under the CrPC, with cases often taking years to reach a verdict. BNSS introduces stricter timelines for investigations and trials, aiming to reduce case backlogs and deliver timely justice.

Key Changes:

  • Time-Bound Investigations: BNSS mandates the completion of investigations within 90 to 180 days, depending on the seriousness of the crime. This is a substantial change from the CrPC, which had general guidelines but lacked strict timelines.

  • Speedy Trials and Fast-Track Courts: The new code emphasizes the establishment of fast-track courts for handling specific types of cases, such as crimes against women and children, thereby ensuring that these cases are resolved promptly.

  • Periodic Case Reviews: BNSS requires regular case reviews to monitor the progress of investigations and ensure that procedural delays are minimized. The CrPC did not have specific provisions for such frequent oversight.

These changes highlight BNSS's commitment to ensuring a quicker resolution of cases, a critical factor in building public trust in the justice system.

4. Enhancing Police Accountability and Oversight Mechanisms

BNSS, 2023, brings in provisions aimed at improving police accountability. While the CrPC outlined general guidelines for police conduct, BNSS strengthens oversight by instituting monitoring mechanisms to prevent abuse of power.

Key Changes:

  • Supervision by Senior Officers: BNSS mandates that senior officers regularly supervise investigations, especially in cases involving sensitive matters, to ensure that junior officers follow proper protocols.

  • Accountability Reports and Audits: Regular audits and reports on police actions are required under BNSS, and any deviations from the established procedures can lead to disciplinary action. The CrPC did not enforce such stringent oversight mechanisms.

  • Limits on Preventive Detention: BNSS imposes clear limits on preventive detention, requiring police officers to justify detentions with solid evidence and logical grounds, unlike the broader authority under the CrPC.

These measures reflect a commitment to holding law enforcement accountable and ensuring fair treatment of suspects.

5. Stronger Victim and Witness Protection

A significant criticism of the CrPC, 1973, was its limited provisions for protecting victims and witnesses, leaving them vulnerable to intimidation or harm. BNSS, 2023, introduces stronger safeguards to protect the interests of victims and witnesses.

Key Changes:

  • Identity Protection for Victims: BNSS mandates the protection of the identities of victims, particularly in cases involving sexual assault or other sensitive crimes, ensuring their privacy and dignity.

  • Witness Protection Schemes: BNSS introduces witness protection measures, especially in serious criminal cases where witnesses face intimidation. Measures include safe housing and legal protections, which were not specified in the CrPC.

  • Victim Compensation: BNSS expands the compensation framework for victims, providing them with the right to financial support from the state in cases of serious injury or loss.

These provisions help create a safer environment for victims and witnesses, encouraging more individuals to participate in the justice process without fear of retaliation.

6. Introduction of Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) Mechanisms

BNSS recognizes the need to relieve the burden on the judicial system by promoting alternative dispute resolution (ADR) methods, such as mediation and arbitration, for minor, non-violent cases. The CrPC did not actively encourage ADR, leading to a backlog of minor cases in the courts.

Key Changes:

  • ADR for Non-Violent Cases: BNSS encourages ADR mechanisms in cases where both parties are willing to negotiate, allowing them to settle disputes out of court.

  • Community Mediation Centers: BNSS calls for establishing mediation centers at the community level, where minor cases can be resolved amicably, reducing the strain on the courts.

These provisions aim to promote amicable resolutions, especially for minor disputes, helping reduce case backlog and freeing up court resources.

7. Simplified and Citizen-Friendly Language

One of the most noticeable aspects of BNSS, 2023, is its use of simplified language, making it more accessible to the general public. The CrPC, 1973, was written in a formal, technical language, making it difficult for ordinary citizens to understand their rights and obligations under the law.

Key Changes:

  • Simplified Legal Terminology: BNSS replaces complex legal jargon with simple, straightforward terms, making the code more understandable to the average citizen.

  • Public Awareness Campaigns: BNSS encourages awareness campaigns to educate citizens about their rights and responsibilities, bridging the knowledge gap and promoting civic awareness.

This language modernization reflects BNSS’s goal of making the criminal justice system more transparent and accessible to all citizens.

Conclusion

The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, represents a landmark reform in India’s criminal justice system, offering much-needed updates to the CrPC, 1973. By enhancing citizens' rights, promoting digitization, ensuring accountability, and expediting judicial processes, BNSS aims to create a more balanced and efficient system. If implemented effectively, BNSS has the potential to not only improve the quality of justice delivery but also increase public trust in the criminal justice system. The reforms signify a new era of justice for India, one that respects individual rights, promotes transparency, and strives for timely justice for all citizens.


 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page